The Modern Victory Garden

Blog

Blog Series - Intensive Planting Practices (Part 1 Raised Beds)

Posted on November 17, 2009 at 11:34 PM

There are many of us who have limited space availability for food production gardening and yet still manage to produce a tremendous amount of our own food supply.   Over the course of several weeks, I plan to devote some of my blogging time to exploring the many techniques available to optimize food production gardening.   There are quite a few topics that relate to this pursuit - including (among others):

  • Crop Selection
  • Intensive Planting Practices
  • Season Extension
  • Soil Management & Fertility

Last week I kicked this blog series off by focusing on Crop Selection.   This week the focus will be on Intensive Planting Practices.   This is a very important topic with several subtopics that are worth discussing at some length.   In order to devote proper attention to these areas (while also sparing your poor eyes the task of reading page after page of blog text!) I am breaking this particular topic into several parts.                               

              

Intensive planting techniques generally include a combination of planting in raised beds (either double dug or otherwise greatly amended and improved), closely spaced planting, intercropping and succession planting, and the use of vertical growing techniques – all for the purpose of producing the same amount of food in approximately 20% of the space used by traditional row gardening practices.   You may be familiar with Mel Bartholomew’s Square Foot Gardening, John Jeavon’s Grow Biointensive method, or Dick Raymond’s Wide Row Gardening.   All of these authors and their recommended practices are using intensive planting techniques in various shapes and forms.   My own gardening style and intensive planting practices have evolved by incorporating and combining elements from of all of these sources, as well as from many others.                              

          

Planting In Raised Beds – Traditional row gardening has plantings in a relatively narrow row - generally spanning several inches in width and with wide strips of walkways in between.   This allows for the easy use of power equipment (rototillers etc) to do weed management and cultivation.   The proportion of growing areas to walkways in a traditional row garden is therefore significantly lower than a garden that utilizes raised garden beds, which generally are 4 feet in width with wide strips of walkways in between. More growing bed area and less walkways translates into greater production per square foot of available garden area.   Wide row gardening also takes advantage of this technique by increasing the width of rows significantly (often 12 to 18 inches wide) but wide rows are still only 1/4th the width of a typical raised garden bed.                 

                        

Raised beds can be created without using any edging materials by simply mounding and shaping the prepared soil into the bed shape.   I prefer to use a boxed edged bed to prevent edge erosion and I also find it discourages accidental walking from occuring in the prepared soil.   Another advantage of a raised boxed edged bed is that it allows me to use a weed whacker to keep the walkways trim and tidy without harming the plants which are safe within the protective edging of the bed.   Finally, boxed edged beds also provide a place to anchor PVC hoops and other structures that are useful for season extension and vertical growing (future topics!).   For all these reasons (plus I think they look nice!), I use edging on all of my garden beds.    

  

 

 

In addition to increasing the amount of planting area per square foot of garden area, raised beds also improve production in that they are generally prepared by either double digging the soil or otherwise deeply cultivating the area and amending the soil.   Mel Bartholomew’s Square Foot Garden method actually calls for the creation of a soil mix that is utilized in place of native amended soil.   This mixture is referred to as Mel’s Mix and is intended to achieve the same result as double digging – creation of a well aerated, well amended soil, that drains well and provides an optimal growing area for plant roots to develop.   My experience has been that double digging provides more optimal results – but it is a great deal of work to create the beds initially.   Using your native soil but improving it significantly has the advantage of less initial cost and generally contains minerals and other bio elements that a manmade mixture will not provide.   You can learn more about double digging a garden bed HERE.   I think it is an investment that yields significant rewards and once completed really does not need to be done again unless you allow compaction to occur by walking within the beds.   Once double dug a bed can be kept aerated by the periodic use of a broad fork or a garden fork and regular additions of compost - which always improves soil structure.   You can read more about prepping garden beds and specifically about using a broad fork HERE.   The advantage of a double dug garden bed is that you have a growing medium that is rich in nutrients and minerals, allows air and water to reach the plants roots, and encourages the colonization of the soil by beneficial creatures (such as worms) and bacteria to break down organic matter in the soil making even more nutrients available to the plants.   My preference for double digging comes in part because it provides a very deep environment of this greatly improved soil structure for roots to really grow and stretch down into – something a more shallowly cultivated or sealed bottom bed will not provide.   The vitality of plants that have been given really ample room for root growth is very apparent when compared to the same plants grown in less “roomy” conditions.           

 

Next week, I will continue the blog series and the focus on intensive planting techniques by discussing the concept of closely spacing plants.

Categories: Blog Series, Garden Beds, Soil

Post a Comment

Oops

  • Oops, you forgot something.
Already a member? Sign In

14 Comments

Reply Heather
10:26 AM on November 18, 2009
I have always had sloped beds, but now will have a few raised. The only problem is that the kids think that they are awfully fun to walk on. They use the edges as a balance beam.
Reply Daphne
04:55 PM on November 18, 2009
I think double digging is so worth the effort. Plants really like the room to spread out their roots. I do find that I have to double dig again though. I double dug a lot of my garden 17 years ago and you wouldn't know it by the soil. I think the freeze/thaws we get (frost can go down feet in my area) bring up rocks and jam them together.

My garden is sloped and for years I only edged the downhill side of the beds, but after a while I found the bed started to shrink because I'd inch in. Now I have most of my beds edged on both sides. By next year they will all be edged. I use a variety of things to edge with, but the most common is just a tree trunk. I have enough dead smallish (8" or less) trees to use from my backyard woods. It makes both my garden neat and my woods neater.
Reply kitsapfreedomgardener
12:29 AM on November 19, 2009
Heather - I have to admit, walking the garden balance bean sounds mighty fun!

Daphne - Does your soil have a fair amount of clay in it? I have had sandy loam of varying sorts for years and years and have not had to work with a more clay mix soil. I had noticed that you use natural tree fall to edge your beds and thought that was pretty darn smart. Good use of the material, looks charming, and certainly is economical.
Reply Daphne
07:10 AM on November 19, 2009
Yes. My soil is heavy clay. That might also make a huge difference about how often to double dig.
Reply Dan
04:53 PM on November 19, 2009
Hi, I have an award for you on my blog. I enjoying reading your posts and thanks for blogging! No need to participate in the awards if you don't want to.
Reply Becky
05:58 PM on November 19, 2009
Do you think the kids would mind if I took over all of the grass in the backyard and made raised beds everywhere? I love the look of the wood edged beds.
I think I may double dig my back garden in the spring. It was sod last spring and then just tilled so it needs some help before the spring comes.
Reply KalenaMichele
01:03 AM on November 20, 2009
Hi! Today I gave you an award on my blog. Thank you for being such an inspiration to me and I really enjoy your blog Also, I've decided to double dig a problem bed I discovered with all the rain we got this month.
Reply kitsapfreedomgardener
07:49 AM on November 20, 2009
Daphne - That was my thought - that a higher proportion of clay would create greater compaction potential regardless of how careful you are not to step on beds etc.

Dan - Thanks for the recognition. I will think about whether to participate in the award. it is nice to be recognized and acknowledged and appreciate your thinking of my site.

Becky - You might have a revolt on your hands if you took away the entire backyard! Double digging is a great way to rejuvenate beds and if you can spare the time and energy - ti is well worth the effort.

KalenaMichele - Thank you for the recognition and award! I hope the double digging improves that bed for you.
Reply Annie's Granny
04:00 PM on November 21, 2009
Another excellent post! You are deserving of all those awards you received ;-)
Reply kitsapfreedomgardener
07:28 PM on November 21, 2009
Hey AG! Glad you enjoyed the post. I figured during the quieter gardening months it would be good to do a focus series to fill in for the lack of garden action blog entries.
Reply Sandy
02:37 PM on November 22, 2009
I am happy to be a student of this series! Thanks for sharing your wonderful knowledge with everyone.
Reply kitsapfreedomgardener
05:08 PM on November 22, 2009
Sandy - I am glad you are finding this useful. Stay tuned... more to come.
Reply Sustainable Eats
10:59 PM on November 28, 2009
What a great post! I love being able to tuck the hoops into the wooden frames as well although I discovered that would work accidentally!
Reply kitsapfreedomgardener
01:11 AM on November 29, 2009
Sustainable Eats - I did not even bother to put brackets to hold the PVC hoops on the newest beds - they work just fine inserted into the soil inside of the edging.